Current:Home > ScamsArtist loses bid to remove panels covering anti-slavery murals at Vermont school-LoTradeCoin
Artist loses bid to remove panels covering anti-slavery murals at Vermont school
View Date:2024-12-23 18:48:23
An artist has lost his appeal to remove fabric panels concealing murals he painted to honor African Americans and abolitionists involved in the Underground Railroad but that officials at the Vermont law school where they’re housed found to be racially insensitive.
Artist Sam Kerson created the colorful murals entitled “Vermont, The Underground Railroad” and “Vermont and the Fugitive Slave” in 1993 on two walls inside a building at the private Vermont Law School, now called Vermont Law and Graduate School, in South Royalton.
In 2020, the school said it would paint over them. But when Kerson objected, it said it would cover them with acoustic tiles. The school gave Kerson the option of removing the murals, but he said he could not without damaging them.
When Kerson, who lives in Quebec, sued in federal court in Vermont, the school said in a court filing that “the depictions of African Americans strikes some viewers as caricatured and offensive, and the mural has become a source of discord and distraction.”
Kerson lost his lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Vermont and appealed. The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York, which heard the case in January, agreed with the lower court in its ruling last Friday.
Kerson didn’t immediately respond on Thursday to an email seeking comment.
“This case presents weighty concerns that pin an artist’s moral right to maintain the integrity of an artwork against a private entity’s control over the art in its possession,” the circuit court panel wrote.
Kerson argued that the artwork is protected by the federal Visual Artists Rights Act, which was enacted “to protect artists against modifications and destruction that are prejudicial to their honor or reputation,” his lawyer, Steven Hyman had said.
He said the covering of the artwork for the purpose of preventing people from viewing it is a modification and that Kerson “must suffer the indignity and humiliation of having a panel put over his art.”
But the school’s lawyer, Justin Barnard, argued that covering the artwork with a wood frame that doesn’t touch the painting and is fixed to the wall is not a modification.
The circuit court, in agreeing with the lower court judge, added that noting in its decision “precludes the parties from identifying a way to extricate the murals” so as to preserve them as objects of art “in a manner agreeable to all. ”
veryGood! (3)
Related
- Georgia lawmaker proposes new gun safety policies after school shooting
- Old legal quirk lets police take your money with little reason, critics say
- Maurice Williams, writer and lead singer of ‘Stay,’ dead at 86
- Matthew Perry Couldn't Speak or Move Due to Ketamine Episode Days Before Death
- Dramatic video shows Phoenix police rescue, pull man from car submerged in pool: Watch
- Thousands of activists expected in Chicago for Democratic convention to call for Gaza ceasefire
- Little League World Series: Updates, highlights from Saturday elimination games
- When does 'Emily in Paris' Season 4 Part 2 come out? Release date, how to watch new episodes
- RHOBH's Kyle Richards Shares Reaction to BFF Teddi Mellencamp's Divorce
- The Bachelor Alum Ben Higgins' Wife Jessica Clarke Is Pregnant With Their First Baby
Ranking
- 'The Penguin' spoilers! Colin Farrell spills on that 'dark' finale episode
- Spanx Founder Sara Blakely Launches New Product Sneex That Has the Whole Internet Confused
- Supermarket store brands are more popular than ever. Do they taste better?
- The Daily Money: Does a Disney+ subscription mean you can't sue Disney?
- Man gets a life sentence in the shotgun death of a New Mexico police officer
- RFK Jr. wants the U.S. Treasury to buy $4M worth of Bitcoin. Here's why it might be a good idea.
- Taylor Swift's best friend since childhood gives birth to sweet baby boy
- What is a blue moon? Here's what one is and what the stars have to say about it.
Recommendation
-
Denzel Washington Will Star in Black Panther 3 Before Retirement
-
Benefit Cosmetics Just Dropped Its 2024 Holiday Beauty Advent Calendar, Filled with Bestselling Favorites
-
Greenidge Sues New York State Environmental Regulators, Seeking to Continue Operating Its Dresden Power Plant
-
Supermarket store brands are more popular than ever. Do they taste better?
-
Wicked Director Jon M. Chu Reveals Name of Baby Daughter After Missing Film's LA Premiere for Her Birth
-
White woman convicted of manslaughter in fatal shooting of Black neighbor
-
How many points did Caitlin Clark score tonight? Rookie shines in return from Olympic break
-
Latest search for 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre victims ends with 3 more found with gunshot wounds